Quakerism on the Precipice: What Happens After the Baby Boomers?
People may be leaving organized religion behind, but the hunger for authentic spiritual connection has never been stronger. So how are modern seekers finding their way to a faith that’s famously reluctant to talk about itself, and how is their fresh energy transforming the meetings they join? This week, we explore those questions through the stories of three seekers who are bringing their newfound energy to their meetings. Join Zack and Jon for a look at the mission behind Thee Quaker Project, and why attracting seekers and energizing Friends matters now more than ever.
Find out more about our work and make a pledge at www.theequaker.org/future.
Subscribe so you don’t miss an episode!
Leave a comment below to share your stories and thoughts!
- Ben Pink Dandelion notes that around 90% of Quakers in Britain today were not born into the movement, but found their way in as seekers. If you weren’t born into Quakerism, what was the specific door or moment that first brought you in—and if you were raised Quaker, what has made you choose to stay?
- Walter Parenteau shares that the first time he attended a Quaker meeting in his twenties, he eventually had to step away because his wounds around Christianity were still too raw. How can our meetings be more mindful of newcomers who walk through the door carrying heavy religious trauma or baggage while also being true to our own religious expressions?
- Walter closes with a challenge to Friends not to just go through the motions of making coffee and sitting down by rote, urging us: “There’s so much depth possible… don’t settle”. In what ways might you or your meeting be “settling” right now, and what is one step you could take toward deeper spiritual vitality?
Zack Jackson
Hey everyone, Zack here. Just a quick word before we get started. On November 24th at 7 PM Eastern Time, we’re hosting a special live Zoom event for podcast supporters. It will be hosted by Quaker lawyer, writer, and advocate Scott Holmes who was featured in last season’s episode, A Quaker Response to Christian Nationalism.
We are living in a time of frighteningly fast cultural and political shifts, but the Early Quaker did too. On November 24th, Scott is going to help us to see the parallels between these two time periods and how we can learn from the wisdom of the Early Quakers to hold power accountable and to protect human dignity today.
We’ll wrap up with a live Q&A, so bring your questions. Can’t make it? The audio and video recording will be available for our podcast supporters. If you aren’t a supporter yet, you can become one for as little as $5. Just visit quakerpodcast.com/support. It only takes a couple minutes, and we really appreciate it.
Zack Jackson
Hey Jon.
Jon Watts
Hi Zack.
Zack Jackson
It’s good to see you, back home in Philly.
Jon Watts
Yeah. It’s good to be home! I’ve been on the road for a while.
Zack Jackson
You’ve been spending a lot of time on the road the past few months, meeting Quakers in person all over the country, so before we dive into this episode about the future of Quakerism, what are you seeing out there now in the present of Quakerism.
Jon Watts
Yeah well… it depends on where you go. Different regions have different flavors of Quakerism, and it is different meeting to meeting, but overall I’d say we’re in a big transition moment as a religious society.
Zack Jackson
Can you say more about that?
Jon Watts
So my parents joined Quakerism in the 1980’s and there was a robust cohort of baby boomers who sort of made up this influx of newcomers to the religion. Their generation was fresh off the Vietnam War and the political violence of the late sixties, and they were attracted to the values of Friends, and found deep mentorship from the older generation in their meeting. As a child of baby boomers, I grew up with sort of my own large Quaker cohort that went through all the Yearly Meetings and camping programs and young meetings together.
But now the baby boomers are aging out, and they are looking to pass the baton, and there’s some anxiety there. Many folks in my generation and younger are busy or checked out or, you know, I have seen a lot of people I grew up with just not being very active or leaving Quakerism altogether.
Zack Jackson
I mean, that’s not a problem unique to Quakerism either. Younger generations have been leaving all sorts of organized religion for decades now.
Jon Watts
Yeah it’s legitimate right? Like if this religious tradition we’re holding is a treasure and we think of ourselves as the stewards, it’s a little sad to consider that it might shrink or dissipate in a significant way.
Zack Jackson
So as you’re out there visiting these meetings, what’s your sense? Are people’s fears about the future actually coming to pass?
Jon Watts
Well in one sense there are some adjustments to be made. You know, I’m seeing meetings asking questions like, what to do about retreat and yearly meeting attendance, what is the purpose of membership, do we really need all these committees? But you know, those are kind of superficial. Like that’s the edifice of Quakerism, is our structures and our buildings and our gatherings, but you know famously Quakerism was founded on the principle that humans can get too focused on the edifice and the form and we often lose sight of the substance.
And along that vein, I’m seeing something pretty exciting. Like, a new energy emerging. A next generation taking form. Like I’ve been to Quaker meetings where the folks attending are mostly under 40. And they’re fired up.
So that’s particularly exciting for me because of my work with Thee Quaker Project. The content we’re publishing through this organization is often a source of inspiration for this next generation.
Zack Jackson
Yeah so thank you for that perfectly tailored segue to this episode, which is all about that… where Quakerism is right now in this shift, where it’s going, and what is energizing this next generation of Quakers? So to answer those questions, I called up some of those Quakers who are leading the next generation and I asked them to tell me their stories.
Zack Jackson
To start us off, I called someone who spends his life looking at the big picture. Ben Pink Dandelion is a professor of Quaker Studies at the University of Birmingham in England, and he’s a part of the learning and research team at Woodbrooke Quaker Study Center. I asked him to put some numbers to that general feeling of decline.
Ben Pink Dandelion
In Britain, where I’m based, we’re seeing very typically amongst particularly liberal religion a decline in numbers, but contrary to earlier predictions, that decline is far less pronounced than people imagined it might be. So there have been articles in the past that said, you know, there’ll be no Quakers in Britain by 2035. And the latest modeling we have is that—I mean numbers are around 10,000 members at the moment, and even in 45 years’ time, we’re still looking at present rates of decline at about 7,000. So it’s by no means a kind of doom-laden end-time prophecy, and just in terms of demographics. I think if we then translate that to North America, we can see a similar trend, probably about 25 years behind.
Zack Jackson
People may be stepping away from organized religion in the West, but they aren’t stepping away from the spirit.
Ben Pink Dandelion
There’s definitely an ongoing, persistent interest in whatever it is that’s beyond the material. So in Britain, 7% going to church, 70% saying they’ve had a personal spiritual experience, or that, you know, they believe in something beyond the material.
Zack Jackson
70%. That is a monumental wave of spiritual hunger, and because of that hunger, the makeup of a typical Quaker meeting has completely flipped on its head over the last century.
Ben Pink Dandelion
And what happens at the beginning of the 20th century is that we generally move away from dynastic Quakerism, family-based Quakerism, to people coming in, and we now have in Britain—and I suspect it’s similar elsewhere—quite a low percentage of people born into the Quaker movement. In Britain it’s about 10%. So that means we’ve got 90% of people coming in. That’s the biggest percentage ever since the 1650s.
Zack Jackson
90% of the room didn’t grow up doing this. They went looking for a spiritual home, and they found Quakerism. People like Jennifer Anthony. Jennifer lives in San Antonio, Texas. A few weeks ago, I was reading through some notes from our supporters, and I came across a single sentence from Jennifer that made me want to learn more. She wrote, “This podcast has become an important part of my journey to Quakerism.” When I called her up to ask what that journey looked like, she told me it started inside a very small circle.
Jennifer Anthony
So I grew up in a church that was fairly egalitarian, but it was still a very, very small circle that was drawn to include a very small number of people, and most of the world, we grew up considering them to be outside of the circle. And going to college, I think, was important to me because I got to meet a lot of different kinds of Christians, and I realized that that circle was not as small as I had thought it was. And once we—I had kids, and we started moving different places and meeting more people, I was really just sort of progressively… I felt like the circle needed to be bigger. And so I found the Episcopalian tradition specifically because they would welcome my brothers and sisters in the LGBTQ+ community. And the theme sort of throughout the decades has just been that the circle is getting wider and wider. And then 2023 is when I started to really look into Quakerism in earnest because, well, I ended up—I read a scripture in Psalms about God bringing us out into a spacious place, and that really resonated with me because I felt like I had grown up in such a cramped place theologically. And so the idea going into Quakerism is maybe there isn’t a circle to draw. Maybe the circle is everyone.
Zack Jackson
Jennifer started reading books by Philip Gulley, and because she loves podcasts, she typed Quaker into her search bar.
Jennifer Anthony
And so I found Thee Quaker podcast, and it just kind of lit up my brain. I was like, “This is it. I just like this way of thinking, a way of being in the world, and seeing other people.”
Zack Jackson
Eventually she worked up the nerve to visit the local meeting in San Antonio. She still considers herself a Quaker hybrid, holding on to her love for the Episcopalian liturgy while wading deeper into the silence of waiting worship. Because when she sits in that meetinghouse, something happens that stays with her long after Sunday morning is over.
Jennifer Anthony
When I think about what it feels like to go there, it’s like lowering a bucket down into a well and pulling it up, and I can like drink from it all week, of just returning to that stillness.
Zack Jackson
For Jennifer, stepping into that spacious place felt like a cool drink of water, but not every seeker who walks through the door of a meetinghouse is ready to stay. Many of us arrive carrying heavy baggage from the religious worlds we left behind, and sometimes even in the most loving of communities, old wounds get reopened. Walter Parenteau is a member of San Francisco Monthly Meeting. Before he found his way to a wooden bench in California, he grew up in a tiny town in northern Vermont.
Walter Parenteau
I was raised in a very Catholic family, and also I’m gay, and I was picked on relentlessly in high school. Had a pretty awful experience, and I kind of—I dug into my Catholic faith. I went to a Catholic school. Two of my great aunts were Catholic nuns, and you know, I went to church every single week growing up. I was profoundly afraid of hell, and because of a combination of the Catholic teachings and the fact that I had never met a gay person, it’s like I didn’t come out to myself till I was 19. So there was a lot of really deep confusion and pain. And when I finally did come out at—let’s see, come out to myself at 19, the Catholic part just collapsed with it because they were so intertwined together, and I spent the majority of my 20s identifying as an atheist.
And when I was 24, one of my friends in San Francisco—this guy who, you know, this circle of friends was kind of like an all-black-wearing anarchic group of young idealists—and one of them was like, “Oh yeah, I go to the Quaker meeting on Sundays.” And my first question was like, “They still exist?” Like I remember hearing about them in school, and I was like, “What do they do?” And he said, “We just sit in silence for an hour.” I sheepishly was like, “Can I go to one?” And he was like, “Yeah.” And so, I attended every week for probably about six months, and I kind of had a hard stop where I decided I wasn’t going to go anymore, and the primary reason was that I was still identifying as an atheist, and Christianity was still very much my main wound. And I often say that the lightly Christian nature of the San Francisco Quaker meeting was too much Christian nature for me at the time because I was still suffering. Like I was really angry at Christianity.
Zack Jackson
After 15 years of intentional seeking and spiritual healing, Walter’s journey led him back to San Francisco and back to that Quaker meeting, where he has found a spiritual home like no other. But Walter’s done more than simply join. His enthusiasm has energized his meeting, and he’s inspiring people to look back at the origins of Quakerism and to rediscover the wild depths of early Quaker worship. They’ve been doing an experiment at their meeting. Whenever there’s a fifth Sunday, they open the meeting for worship 90 minutes early.
Walter Parenteau
When there are five or six or eight of us sitting there for an hour and a half before everyone comes in, those meetings are deeper. I have no doubt about that whatsoever. It’s just like the second everyone enters and sits down, there’s usually a message in the first 10 minutes, and it already feels rich. I’m still on the hunt for answers to what has changed from the 1600s to us today, but I think more and more I’m leaning in one direction, which is, I think largely what has been lost is just the amount of time people spent in silence and in worship, and I think that one hour a week on Sunday is not enough. I think nearly every practicing Quaker would agree with me that when you sit for an hour, the last 10 or 15 minutes are richer than the 40 minutes before it. So it always feels so crazy to me that right when it gets rich, we hop up and go get coffee. It’s like it literally just started getting good.
Zack Jackson
In our loud, fast, attention-driven world, stillness is a radical act. Marketing experts will tell you that people are attracted to quick, exciting stimulation, but Ben Pink Dandelion has seen that seekers are really after depth and connection—something that Quakers have been doing for a long time.
Ben Pink Dandelion
And Quakerism is essentially a mystical faith. I think Quakers are unusual in basing everything upon a mystical encounter, whether or not it’s programmed or unprogrammed, or you know, pastor-aided or not. That mystical encounter is at the heart of the Quaker faith. I have a dear friend who keeps saying, you know, we just need to get back to the barn. Let’s get back to the barn Quakerism. We can meet anywhere, any time, you know, in any space. A lot of Quakers will have their spiritual experience outside of meeting. The meeting is an intentional attempt to deepen that possibility of encounter, but it doesn’t mean that everything then stops at the end of meeting. You know, Thomas Kelly talks about a life of prayer without ceasing. That to me is Quakerism.
Zack Jackson
People are hungry for the wildness of the barn and a silence so rich that you don’t want to leave it for coffee. When seekers find this well, it changes their lives and their hunger wakes up the whole meeting. But, how on earth are people supposed to find their way to the Meeting if Quakers are famously reluctant to tell anyone that they still exist, and what happens when a brand new seeker walks through the digital front door, falls in love with friends, and actually gets handed the keys to the meeting? We’ll find out right after the break. Stay tuned.
Zack Jackson
So Jon, we mentioned at the top of the show that you’ve been traveling a lot among Friends. Lets take a moment here mid-way through the show to put a finer point on it… you’ve been traveling because you’re seeking support for this vision for the future of Friends.
Jon Watts
Yeah. Well, it has been a busy and an exciting period here behind the scenes at Thee Quaker Project. We now have all 3 of our media projects up and running, which include this podcast, a daily quaker email, and a weekly video project which is also posting shortform content. We’ve also built a robust social media presence which is reaching hundreds of thousands of people every month, and just generally putting a major dent in this problem of Quakers hiding their light under a bushel. The light is starting to stream out.
We’re hearing from listeners and readers and viewers every day that these projects are helping them to discover the Quaker path, helping them to deepen their relationship to Quakerism, and to build spiritual community. There are a lot more Quakers today because of this work.
Zack Jackson
You know, just the other day, I spoke with one of our listeners, a fierce human rights activist in Ireland who uses our podcast to teach newcomers about how relevant Quakerism is today. She told me that she keeps her favorite episodes downloaded so when the world feels too heavy, she can replay them to find the comfort and inspiration to keep going.
Jon Watts
So we’ve launched these three projects, they are growing and having an impact. And you know, in order to make something really good, we have to invest in it. These projects cost money.
I’m happy to say that each of them is on its way to financial sustainability. This podcast, for example, raised 50% of its operating expenses last year. That’s amazing for the third year of a project like this. If you are a supporter of this show, you helped make that happen.Thank you.
I’m here to talk about the other 50%. For the past two years I have been on the road traveling and raising support for what we’re calling the Attracting Seekers, Energizing Friends campaign. I’m so excited to say that we’re 90% of the way to our goal.
So now in the last two months of this campaign, we’re reaching out to you, dear listeners, and asking you to consider making a pledge to this campaign. It just takes a few minutes
You can do it with a credit card, a check, an IRA, a donor advised fund, a gift of stock… however you want to do it! It’s simple and there is an option for you. Go to theequaker.org/future to find out more, and thank you so much. Now back to the show.
Zack Jackson
Welcome back. Before the break, we talked to two very different seekers who found their way to meetings that changed their lives in unexpected ways, which brings me to Don Hutchinson in Cincinnati, Ohio. Don didn’t grow up Quaker. In fact, his path into the Religious Society of Friends started on his couch, watching a cable television drama about George Washington’s spy ring.
Don Hutchinson
So it was a TV show called Turn, and there was a string of episodes that focused on this like Quaker family and their involvement in this spy ring and like, does that violate their, you know, pacifist tendencies? And so they really grappled with it, and there were several scenes where they were challenged in their faith, and it really got me thinking like, “Oh, what’s Quakerism about? I’ve never really dove into it.” So then, when I started digging into Quakerism, it was checking a lot of boxes, and I just remember I think maybe on like the second day of learning about Quakerism online, I came across the QuakerSpeak videos, and I was getting a little freaked out because I thought, “Oh no, I think I’m a Quaker.” So then I started Googling like, “Why can’t I be a Quaker?” And I was like, “Are gay people allowed to be Quakers?” And it was like, “Yeah, gay people are welcome.” And then I started trying to come up with excuses like, “Why can’t I be a Quaker?” And I even Google searched like, “Oh, bad things Quakers have done,” and it was always articles about like Quakers being self-critical that they didn’t do more, or Quakers complaining that they were slow to act on abolition, or they were slow to stand up for the vote, or you know… But it was all self-critical, and I thought like, “Oh my gosh, like I think I’m just gonna have to go to a meeting.”
Zack Jackson
Four years ago, Don moved to Cincinnati with his husband and joined Community Friends Meeting. And he didn’t just join. Today, this millennial who found Quakers through a TV show is the presiding clerk of his meeting. He also sits on the outreach committee. I asked Don what stops Friends from attracting more seekers like him.
Don Hutchinson
For many, they get kind of bogged down in the details, and I think a big part of it is like Quakers are so concerned about saying everything 100% right or that it’s understood 100% in the right way, and that’s where we like trip ourselves up, and we lose the whimsy. Quakers, if nothing else, are whimsical.
Zack Jackson
I love how much Don uses the word whimsy. We talk a lot in Quaker circles about simplicity, peace, integrity, all very weighty, serious words. So I asked Don why whimsy is such an important spiritual practice for him.
Don Hutchinson
So I think why I like to use the word whimsy, or why I think it’s important, is like you look around your meetings and you see like such fantastical members. Even the ones who might not be the most colorful in expression or the loudest, but they’ve got these like super interesting hobbies, or maybe they’ve volunteered with an organization for 30 years, and they’re just like really into it. And I think we sometimes don’t highlight enough like the zeal that Quakers have for life.
Zack Jackson
And that zeal for life? That mystical connection to the divine and deep connection to a local community? He’s convinced that it’s what the world needs now more than ever.
Don Hutchinson
I think Quakerism has a lot to offer, to any generation, but I think specifically to my generation. I’m a millennial. I was born in ’92, and a lot of folks my age who grew up in similar faiths were promised a faith and community that treated everyone equally, that helped the poor, that looked out for their neighbor.
And, you know, a lot of folks I’ve talked to fell out of their churches because when they grew up, they weren’t seeing that reflected, and that became something that made, I think, a lot of us very jaded. Quakerism is, it’s one of the few where I found that there’s so much emphasis on our actions and how we’re living and coming together in a community, um, that I think a lot of people would respond really well to.
I like to tell my friends that Quakerism is a spiritual journey that you take on your own in a community of believers, and it’s a way of allowing you to grow and develop and find your spiritual understanding while being supported by people who also want the best for you.
So I think it’s a faith that really works for people who are seekers and people who have a lot of questions and for people who want to live and work together in a community, um, that really lives those values. I just think we have a lot to offer people right now who are seeking a community, and not just something that’s just on Sundays.
Zack Jackson
Hey, Jon. Welcome back. You know, sitting here listening to Jennifer, Walter, Ben, and Don back to back. I’m struck by how much they sound like the stories that you’ve been bringing back from the road, and so I’m wondering as we close out this episode, what about you? What’s energizing you? What’s your prayer for the future of Quakerism?
Jon Watts
Hmm. Yeah. Well, you know, I I talked about the transition that we’re going through as a Religious Society of Friends, and you know, I think that while transitions are scary, they are also full of opportunity, so I just want to say to our listeners, especially to the millennials or younger, you know, it’s it’s time to step up, and I don’t mean that in terms of like burdening you with the responsibility of maintaining the status quo of your Quaker meeting.
I mean it like there is room for you, right now, to bring your vision forward. If you’re attending a Quaker meeting and you feel a leading or a nudge that something about the community or the worship could be different or it could be deeper, come forward with that. There’s life in that, and thank you for your faithfulness.
By the way, we asked this question: What’s your prayer for the future of Quakerism? On our Facebook page, and we got over 100 responses. Some of them brought tears to my eyes, and we published some of our favorites on the Daily Quaker website. So, just wanted to recommend that you check those out. Thank you.
Zack Jackson
Thank you for listening and thank you to our guests, Ben Pink Dandelion, Jennifer Anthony, Walter Parentau, and Don Hutchinson.
This episode was edited and produced by me, Zack Jackson. Our executive producer is Jon Watts. With editorial support from our creative team, Maeve Sutherland and Adam Ginsberg—and a member of Thee Quaker board. All the music in this episode was composed and recorded by Jon Watts.
Thee Quaker Podcast is a part of Thee Quaker Project. As you heard today, we are a nonprofit Quaker media organization dedicated to giving Quakerism a platform for the 21st Century. If you have been blessed by this work and you want to make sure that we are able to continue growing, please consider going to theequaker.org/future where you can find out more about how you can be a part of this mission. Again, that’s theequaker.org/future. We’ll put a link in the show notes.
We’ll be back in your feed on the first and third Tuesday of every month this season, so make sure you’re subscribed.
And now. Our daily Quaker message as read by Grace Gonglewski.
Grace Gonglewski
“The Quaker discovery and message has always been that God still lives and moves, works and guides, in vivid immediacy, within the hearts of men. For revelation is not static and complete, like a book, but dynamic and enlarging, as springing from a Life and Soul of all things.” Thomas R. Kelly
Zack Jackson
To get Quaker wisdom in your inbox every day, go to dailyquaker.com. That’s dailyquaker.com.
Hosted, produced, and edited by Zack Jackson.
Executive produced by Jon Watts
Editorial Support by Maeve Sutherland, Adam Ginsberg, and a member of Thee Quaker Board
Original music by Jon Watts (Listen to more of Jon’s music here.)
This season’s cover art is by Joey Hartmann-Dow.
Season 4 is sponsored by The Friends Committee on National Legislation (FCNL)
Supported by listeners like you (thank you!!)
